Not always. The American Dental Association says silver (amalgam) fillings that are in good condition are safe and do not need to be removed. Replacing old fillings makes sense when a filling is cracked, worn, leaking or has new decay around it, or when you want a more natural look and your dentist agrees the tooth is a good fit for a tooth-colored filling.
How do you know if an old filling needs to be replaced?
Your dentist checks your fillings at every exam. Most problems are found there, often before you feel anything. That is one more reason to keep your regular dental exams.
Signs a filling may need attention include:
- A crack or chip you can see or feel with your tongue
- A dark line or stain around the edge of the filling
- Food that keeps catching in the same spot
- New sensitivity to hot, cold or sweet foods
- Pain when you bite down on that tooth
- A filling that feels rough, loose or has fallen out
Every filling wears out eventually. Fillings wear down from chewing over many years. When the seal at the edge breaks down, bacteria can slip underneath and start new decay. Catching that early usually means a smaller repair.
What is the difference between silver and white fillings?
Silver fillings are made of dental amalgam, a mix of metals. White fillings are made of composite resin, a tooth-colored material that is shaded to match your tooth. Both are used to fill cavities, but they differ in a few ways.
| Silver (amalgam) fillings | White (composite) fillings | |
|---|---|---|
| Color | Silver, does not match tooth color | Matched to your tooth color |
| How it attaches | Held in by the shape of the cavity | Bonded to the tooth |
| Placement time | Usually shorter | Usually longer, the tooth must stay dry |
| Best suited for | Many sizes of cavity | Small to mid-size fillings, front or back teeth |
| Durability | Long track record | Good for small to mid-size fillings; the ADA notes they may need replacing sooner than silver |
| Cost | Usually lower | Usually higher, some plans pay less |
At Buffalo 215 Dental, new cavities are filled with white composite fillings. You can read more about the material and the steps on our dental fillings page.
Are silver fillings safe to keep?
For most people, yes. The ADA says amalgam is a safe and effective filling material, and that existing amalgam fillings in good condition do not need to come out.
The FDA does recommend that certain higher-risk groups (including people who are pregnant or nursing, young children, and people with mercury allergy, kidney problems or certain nerve conditions) avoid getting new amalgam fillings when possible and appropriate.
Even so, the FDA does not recommend removing amalgam fillings that are in good condition with no decay under them. Taking out a healthy filling can mean losing some healthy tooth structure, and it briefly releases more mercury vapor during removal. If you are pregnant, planning a pregnancy, or have a health condition you are worried about, talk it over with your dentist and physician.
Can you replace silver fillings just for looks?
Yes, in many cases. Some people do not like seeing dark fillings when they laugh or smile. If a silver filling is visible and you want a more natural look, ask your dentist whether a white filling is a good option for that tooth.
Your dentist will look at how big the old filling is and how much healthy tooth is left. A very large filling may leave the tooth weak. In that case, a dental crown can protect the tooth better than a new filling. It helps to plan replacements one or two teeth at a time, starting with any that are already failing.
What happens when a filling is replaced?
Replacing a filling is a lot like getting a new one. Here is how it usually goes at Buffalo 215 Dental:
- The dentist numbs the area with local anesthetic.
- The old filling and any decay under it are removed.
- The tooth is cleaned and prepared.
- The white filling is shaded to match your tooth, placed in layers and hardened.
- The filling is polished and your bite is checked and adjusted.
Most people go back to normal activities right away. Your lip and cheek may feel numb for a few hours, so wait until the numbness wears off before you eat. Mild sensitivity for a few days is common. If your bite feels high or the tooth stays sore, call so the dentist can adjust it.
When to see a dentist about an old filling
Book a visit if a filling has cracked or fallen out, if a tooth with a filling hurts when you bite, or if you notice new sensitivity or a dark edge around a filling. Do not wait for pain. A small leak around a filling can turn into deeper decay, and that can mean a crown or a root canal instead of a simple repair.
At our Las Vegas office, Dr. Gill checks your fillings with an exam and X-rays, explains what she sees, and gives you your options and an estimate before any work starts. Learn more about the visit on our dental fillings page.
FAQ
How long do white fillings last?
It depends on the size of the filling, where it is in your mouth, your bite and how you care for your teeth. Small to mid-size composite fillings hold up well. Your dentist will check them at each visit.
Does replacing a filling hurt?
The area is numbed first, so most people feel pressure and vibration rather than pain. Some sensitivity afterward is common and usually fades within days.
Will insurance pay to replace a silver filling?
Many plans help pay to replace a filling that is broken or has decay under it. Some plans pay less for white fillings on back teeth, and cosmetic-only changes may not be covered. Buffalo 215 Dental offers a free benefits check so you know your estimated cost first.
Can all my old fillings be replaced at once?
Sometimes, but it is often better to replace them a few at a time, starting with those that are failing. Your dentist can help you plan an order that fits your needs and budget.
Have questions about your old fillings?
Buffalo 215 Dental in Las Vegas can check your fillings and talk through your options. Call or text (702) 505-9199, or contact us online to book a visit at 6530 South Buffalo Drive, Suite 105.
